Kempsey Shire Council has knocked back a contentious proposal for a 27-apartment development near sensitive coastal wetlands in South West Rocks, with the developer promising to take the fight back to court. 

During Tuesday’s council meeting, councillor Alexandra Wyatt raised questions over the “environmental suitability” of the development site in terms of future sea level rise and “long-term stability”.

  • “What happens in 20, 30, even 50 years if environmental conditions change … ” she asked the chamber.

    “Developers may complete the project, sell the apartments and move on. However, the future property owners and the council and the broader community may be left dealing with a long-term impact and cost.” 

What happened: In May, developer Rise Projects submitted an application for the development – a three-storey apartment block with a basement car park on land behind Front Beach in South West Rocks.

An assessment of the proposal was then undertaken by an independent planner, considering issues including stormwater, hydrology and groundwater. 

The decision: On Tuesday, councillors voted not to approve the $10.6 million project, in line with the recommendation of the assessment.

The site: The proposed apartment block is part of a broader plan for an expansive beachside development site on Phillip Drive.

  • Having sat vacant for decades, Rise Projects applied for a construction certificate to commence works on the site in 2021, seeking to use an approved DA issued more than 30 years ago. 

The council knocked them back initially, but this decision was eventually reversed in the Land and Environment Court.

Work commences: Since then, vegetation has been cleared from the site and 18 townhouses built. A two-storey “resort” building is also currently under construction.

A separate application for multiple four and five storey apartment blocks was refused by the Northern Regional Planning Panel in 2024. An appeal by the developer was dismissed by the Land and Environment Court in 2025.

Reasons for refusal: The assessment offered 10 reasons why the council recommended refusing the newly-proposed 27-apartment block - described as Stage 2A of Rise’s development plan. 

  • This included proposed building heights 4.2 metres above the local standard, issues with the project’s design and quality, and housing density. 

  • The assessment also raised concerns over parking, the site’s suitability, and the project’s reliance on shared community land and stormwater arrangements given the proximity of the wetlands.

Community feedback: Council received 34 submissions, all objecting to the proposal.

One was from South West Rocks resident Warren Bailey, who said protection of the wetlands was a priority for many locals. 

  • “[They] are not only vitally important ecologically but also socially and economically,” he said.

What next: Rise Projects’ managing director, Daniel Pszczonka, said he intends to appeal the decision “immediately” in the Land and Environment Court. 

He claimed the council failed to seek clarification on aspects of the application they later used as grounds to refuse the proposal.

  • “We put all effort into making the DA as comprehensive and detailed as possible to give Council every opportunity to scrutinise the proposal, raise issues, and we would revise and improve the application where needed to address all Council concerns,” he told the Mid North Coaster.

    “We are extremely disappointed in Council’s assessment, and the manner in which they represented themselves.”

Not the issue: He also played down worries over environmental risks.

  • “Councillors talked about floods and sea level rise, but Council’s own staff report found that flooding, sea level rise, contamination and acid sulfate soils are not reasons for refusal,” he said.

Cost to ratepayers: Pszczonka warned council may “waste hundreds of thousands of dollars of ratepayer’s money on this case, and future cases”. 

  • “Ratepayers who were just hit with a 7.5 percent rate rise will now pay for a court case Council can’t afford, with many more court cases to come in the years ahead.”

Court consideration: Regarding the risk of a court appeal, Councillor Wyatt said councillors should not “feel pressured to support development applications simply because of the prospect of legal proceedings and the potential cost of defending our position” . 

“Our role is to make decisions based on the planning merits before us,” she said. 

Project benefits: Pszczonka said the proposal offers much-needed housing options for young people and retirees, and boosts the local economy and creates jobs.

  • “Locals need homes they can actually afford. Apartments cost less than a house on a large block,” he said.

“Stage 2A will contribute another $12m in construction value that spreads through the community paying people’s incomes, material supply etc. Hundreds of individuals from South West Rocks, Kempsey Shire, and the Mid North Coast have spent time working on our site.”