One Nation has vowed to scrap the Great Koala National Park (GKNP), announcing a policy one of Australia’s leading ecologists has described as making “no economic sense”.
Dr David Lindenmayer, who has researched Australian forests for decades, said the party’s policy announcement last week read like “Donald Trump on steroids”.
“They simply haven't done their homework about the industry or the technical details of what they are saying,” he said.
What happened: One Nation representatives made the announcement on Friday at the premises of Weathertex, a Port Stephens manufacturer of timber weatherboards and wall cladding panels.
Legislation to create the GKNP passed through parliament last month, protecting 178,000 hectares of former state forest - between Kempsey and Woolgoolga - from future logging.
Why oppose it?: One Nation senator Sean Bell said the party would work - at federal and state levels - to overturn both the GKNP and a similar proposal in the state’s south.
A social media post, released alongside the announcement, claimed “22,000 timber industry jobs” are at stake through Labor’s decision to “lock up our forests”.
The numbers: According to the state government, 22,000 is around the total number of people across NSW employed in logging and related jobs, such as timber wholesaling, forestry support services, and paper and wood product manufacturing.
Lindenmayer said One Nation’s figure of 22,000 job losses relating to native forest logging cuts is “about 21,000 out”, citing an assessment undertaken by consultancy Frontier Economics in 2021.
Party’s position: Speaking on Friday, One Nation NSW leader Mike Newman suggested the park’s creation was the result of the government prioritising ideology over economics.
He said the government is committed to shutting down the timber industry “in order to chase carbon credits”.
He also claimed logging has “next to no impact at all” on koala populations, citing a 2024 DPI study which found timber harvesting had “no influence on extinction probability” for the species.
Not so simple: Lindenmayer said Newman’s comments had “grossly oversimplified” the impacts of logging on koalas and other native species.
He said tree harvesting can change the composition of forests, affecting koala habitat and food supply, and increasing the severity of bushfires.
“Across NSW, native forest logging negatively impacts an estimated 150 species, and the average logging coupe across NSW is home to about eight threatened species.”
Economic argument: One Nation’s claims that NSW would be economically worse off without a native timber industry don’t stack up either, Lindenmayer said.
The native forest division of Forestry Corporation of NSW - which manages logging in NSW state forests - made a loss of $32 million for the 2024–25 financial year. It has not recorded a profit from native forest logging in more than 10 years.
“The reason why the Minns government wants an end to native forest logging is economics – the industry costs the taxpayer hundreds of millions,” he said.
“It would be financially disastrous to bring back a native forest logging industry in an area where the industry loses large amounts of money.”
What about the wood?: Another of Friday’s speakers, Stuart Bonds - a One Nation upper house hopeful - claimed the GKNP would mean a shortage of materials needed to build new homes.
He also went in to bat for the industry’s sustainability practices, suggesting images shared of “clear felled” forests, where every tree in a specific area is logged, are “false”.
Power of plantations: In response, Lindenmayer said concerns about a lack of wood supply are misguided, given “90 percent of all sawn timber in Australia comes from plantations” as opposed to native forests.
“I've heard this fallacious argument over and over and over again that we need to keep logging our forests to build millions of houses,” Lindenmayer said.
“You're dealing with two very different industries here: a plantation sector that produces most of our sawn timber, and a native forest logging sector that produces wood chips, paper pulp, box liners and packaging materials.”
What’s in a name: In response to Bonds’ claim that forests aren’t “clear felled” in NSW, Lindenmayer said clear felling did effectively occur - but under a different name.
“There's no doubt that in some places … there's very intensive logging operations, including behind Coffs Harbour, where the operations leave very few trees - whether you call that clear felling or intensive selective harvesting is semantics,” he said.
“To suggest that because we're not doing intensive clear felling everywhere, that the effects are benign, completely misunderstands how forests work.”
